
Did Dystopian Literature Fail?
11/17/2026 | 14m 43sVideo has Closed Captions
Authoritarians have always had a special relationship with storytelling and enforcing obedience.
From the real world to our favorite dystopian novels and shows, authoritarians have always had a special relationship with storytelling. Enforcing obedience requires careful control of the narrative: walking the fine line of censoring the stories that threaten your objectives like in Fahrenheit 451 or Silo, and seeding the propaganda that will maintain your power.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback

Did Dystopian Literature Fail?
11/17/2026 | 14m 43sVideo has Closed Captions
From the real world to our favorite dystopian novels and shows, authoritarians have always had a special relationship with storytelling. Enforcing obedience requires careful control of the narrative: walking the fine line of censoring the stories that threaten your objectives like in Fahrenheit 451 or Silo, and seeding the propaganda that will maintain your power.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch PBS Plotlines
PBS Plotlines is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- I may be alone on this, but I actually don't find apocalypse stories like "The Last of Us" or "The Road" all that scary.
I mean, sure, I don't want to be torn apart by zombies, or incinerated by an asteroid, but I also know those things are probably never going to happ at least not in my lifetime.
What makes me more afraid for th are authoritarian dystopias like or "The Handmaid's Tale," ones that envision systemic oppr under some kind of all-powerful ruling entity, whether it's being chosen a tribute for "The Hunger Games," or being trapped in a simulated by intelligent machines in "The They feel chillingly possible.
And dare I say, familiar?
- Deja vu.
- After all, many dystopian writers have drawn from historical regimes to warn us of their dangers blind submission to authority, repression of individua thought, propaganda, censorship, and power concentrated in the hands of a small elite.
But how accurate are these dark visions of the future?
Do stories really have the power to set us free?
Or are they even more effective at keeping us subjugated?
(mysterious music) In 1949, Aldous Huxley wrote a personal letter to George Orwell, arguing that his dystopian novel, "Brave New World," depicted a more likely future than the one in Orwell's "Nineteen Eighty-Four."
Talk about the most depressing pen pals ever.
Huxley wrote, "The lust for power can be just as completely satisfied by suggesting people into loving their servitude as by flogging and kicking them into obedience."
It's an interesting question that several dystopian novels contend with.
How will authoritarians control Through pleasure, or pain?
Strength, or seduction?
If you look at the dystopian genre since then, many depictions of authoritarian are variations on these two clas In 1984, George Orwell tackled totalitarianism.
With reoccurring themes o sexual repression, secret police omnipresent government surveilla (Big Brother is watching you!)
and constant propaganda to destroy independent thought.
War is peace.
Freedom is slavery Ignorance is strength.
There have been countless books that feature similar regimes, like the surveillance state of Suzanne Collins's "The Hunger Games," or the IT department's oversight of the residents in "Silo."
"Nineteen Eighty-Four" was based on Nazi Germany and Stalinist Russia, real world dictatorships of Orwell's past and present.
But Huxley was a little more forward thinking.
He saw the rise of consumerism and second wave industrializatio as leading to a form of authorit based not on fear and pain, but pleasure and excess.
He borrowed the structure of Ford's moving assembly line to literally envision ho humans could be mass produced, and indoctrinated in labs to love their lot in life.
The residents of Huxley's world are sexually unrepressed, and constantly consume a soothin happiness-producing drug called There are echoes of "Brave New W in the TV show "Severance."
Employees at Lumon Industries undergo a procedure that splits their memorie between work and personal lives, industrial augmentation of human psychology to ensure tranquility.
Instead of ignorance i strength, its ignorance is bliss which is not coincidentally an i from "The Matrix."
- Ignorance is bliss.
- Another story about assembly l kept passive by a comforting fic Ray Bradbury's "Fahrenheit 451" also foresees a future of mindless drug and TV use, where citizens waste their lives in TV parlors surrounded by flat screen TVs and listening to seashells in th That one hits pretty close to ho Even Pixar's "WALL-E" can be int as a kind of kid's version of "Brave New World."
Getting to live on a starship with a screen attached to your hovering recliner seems great in theory, until you realize that a psychot is keeping you submissive by giving you every comfort in the world.
ChatGPT would never, right?
Interestingly, all these examples depict oppression that is the same for all members of a society, which, let's face it, has never really been the case.
Many, if not most authoritarian regimes derive power from the demonization an subjugation of minority groups like Jews, immigrants, and LGBTQ In a Guardian article from 2013, Margaret Atwood wrote, "The majority of dystopias, Orwell's included, have been written by men, and the point of view has been m When women have appeared in them they have been either sexless automatons or rebels who have defied the sex rules of the regime.
I wanted to try a dystopi from the female point of view, the world according to Julia, as a reference to the love interest of "Nineteen Eighty-Four," who doesn't get great treatment from Orwell.
In her 1985 novel, "The Handmaid Atwood writes of a patriarchal totalitarian state, known as the Republic of Gilead.
The United States government has been overthrown by a form of puritanical Christi and women known as Handmaids are forced to bear children for high class men and their infertile wives.
Unfortunately, Atwood's dystopia simply places White women under the oppression that Black and Brown women have faced for centuries, and which can be traced back as far as the transatlantic slav which three-time Hug Award-winning author N.K.
Jemisi explores expertly in her "Broken Earth" trilogy.
In a far-flung future of climate catastrophe, a persecuted cast of magically powered people known as Orogenes are taken to t to be indoctrinated and forcibly to serve the needs of the non-magical society.
But Octavia E. Butler's "Earthseed" duology published in the '90s is perhaps my favorite dystopian Set in a future United States, ravaged by climate change, growing wealth inequality and corporate greed, fascism is on the rise.
And far right leaders rally the under extreme nationalism and White supremacy.
Which brings up an uncomfortable Does this genre really make a di Do stories about authoritarian d actually discourage us fro walking straight down that path?
"Fahrenheit 451" is one o the most famous American books of the 20th century.
It's still a staple in high school English classes.
And yet, here we all are, consuming hours of mind-numbing content through screens and the seashells in our ears.
Despite Orwell's warning about surveillance states, we voluntarily share every detail of our lives with oligarchic mega corporation And despite "The Matrix" becomin one of the biggest movie franchises of all time, people are forsaking reality in favor of AI-designed delusion Not to mention the fact that the film's metaphor of taking the red pill has been to mean believe everything the algorithm feeds you, the exact opposite of its original meaning.
In fact, there's an argument to that storytelling is just a much a tool of authoritarians, as it is a weapon against them.
All these regimes, fictional and totalitarian, consumerist or rel use narratives as a key method o And many start with the mos basic element of storytelling.
Heroes, and villains.
In Orwell's "Nineteen Eighty-Fou the party casts Big Brother as the revolutionary hero, plastered on posters and revered and Goldstein as the backstabbin the enemy of the people to be verbally abused in the Two Minutes Hate each day In actuality, these two characte were based on Joseph Stali and Leon Trotsky respectively.
Trotsky, like Goldstein, ha been ostracized from the party, and cast as a political oppositi in the wake of Lenin's death and the power vacuum that follow so that Stalin could wrest contr In Ray Bradbury's "Fahrenheit 45 Captain Beatty tells Montag he thinks of the firemen as the Happiness Boys, and says, "We stand against the small tide who want to make everyone unhapp with conflicting theory and thou Here, the intellectuals of old, the annoying nerd in class, are awful purveyors of misery, while the book-burning firemen a As if we nerds haven't suffered But there's a paradox in the typical authoritarian's hero/villain dynamic.
How do you portray yourself as a strong, dominant Ubermensch who also happens to be a victim of nerds and losers?
In fiction, this is often accomp with a betrayal plot point.
"Braveheart" hero William Wallac only loses on the battlefields because he's backstabbed by the Scottish nobles.
In the "Star Wars" prequels, the Jedi council is brought down by a traitor in their ranks.
And in Virgil's "Aeneid," the Trojans only lose the city because of that stupid horse.
Betrayal allows th protagonists to suffer a defeat without looking weak while setti for a glorious redemption.
The same technique shows up in real world authoritarians' na Hitler's rise to power, for inst was facilitated by the stab-in-the-back myth, which imagined that the Germans would have won World War I if it weren't for the Jew who undermined them back home.
Failures of the Soviet state were blamed on sabotage by disloyal insiders.
And the Ku Klux Klan spread across the American South, thanks in part to rumors that no were conspiring with Blacks to rig their elections.
Authoritarians also make heavy use of the golden era trope.
"The Lord of the Rings" is thematically stuffed with fallen kingdoms, fading glory, and waning magic.
At the end, Aragorn's coronation is a promise of return to the good old days.
It's no wonder that Italian neo- have such an affinity for the bo establishing hobbit camps as ear to discuss their love of Tolkien and totalitarianism.
Italian dictator Benito Mussolin was similarly obsessed with anci erecting grandiose buildings, mo and arches to echo the empire's In Butler's dystopia, President Andrew Steele Jarret uses his slogan, "Make America Great Again," to mobilize his followers into cleansing America of non-Christian faiths, which have supposedly ruined the Jarret's slogan was likely model Ronald Reagan's own use o "Let's Make America Great Again" in his 1980 presidential campaig - We'll make America great again - [Jananie] Which was later adop by another American president, who trademarked the phrase in 20 - We will make America great aga - I got to admit, it's a little depressing to realize how much authoritarians and auto have benefited from storytelling And yet it's important t remember that they also fear it.
It's not enough to tell your sto You have to make sure no one else gets to tell theirs.
In totalitarian regimes, that means outright suppression.
Book bans, book burnings, arrest and persecution of writers and p It's no coincidence that the demagogic senator, Joseph McCarthy, went so hard after Hollywood.
He knew the power of stories to influence thinking.
But modern authoritarians have l that you don't have to silence your opponents, you can also drown them out.
Russian president Vladimir Putin is known for a propaganda approa that gives people so many conflicting narratives that determining what's true is like finding a needle in a ha In "Amusing Ourselves to Death," media scholar Neil Postman contr the two forms of thought control What Orwell feared were those who would ban books.
What Huxley feared was that there would be no reason to ban a book, for there would be no one who wanted to read one.
Orwell feared those who would deprive us of information.
Huxley feared those who would give us so much that we would be reduced to passivity and egoism.
Orwell feared that the truth would be concealed from us.
Huxley feared the truth would be in a sea of irrelevance.
In short, Orwell feared that what we hate will ruin us.
Huxley feared that what we love will ruin us.
Postman was specifically worried that the rapid pace and sensory overload of new media like television made it a useful tool for those who wish to distract and control In contrast, books give reader much more space to think, to reason, to disagree.
Ray Bradbury expresses a similar in "Fahrenheit 451."
"You can shut books, say, 'Hold on a moment.'
You play God to it.
But who has ever torn himself from the claw that encloses you when yo drop a seed in a TV and parlor?
It grows you any shape it wishes It is an environment as real as It becomes and is the truth.
Books can be beaten down with re but with all my knowledge and sk I have never been able to argue with a 100-piece symphony orchestra, full color, three dimensions, and being in and part of those incredible parlors."
None of these authors lived to see social media become the dominant format of ou but if they thought TV was good at distracting us, they hadn't seen anything yet.
Their encouragement to read more although decades old, seems more important than ever r And yet everyone's guilty o getting sucked into the scroll from time to time.
When you look up in a digital daze, and think, "Wow, that was not a good way to spend four hours."
At times like that, it can feel like we're livin in Huxley's "Brave New World," where stories of value are drown in an ocean of mindless content.
But hey, you found this video, so maybe there's hope after all.


- Science and Nature

We give you deep answers to simple questions about science and the rest of the universe.



New Episode

New Episode
New Episode
New Season


Support for PBS provided by:

